A new football league season and a new show for the Saturday night highlights.
First Channel 5 deserve massive congratulations for putting the Football League Tonight show on at 9pm prime time to run up before Match of the Day, rather than the later night slot which BBC used.
It shows a commitment to using the highlights as a prime bit of TV coverage.
Unfortunately that’s pretty much where the praise ends I’m afraid.
Clearly the producers have decided that they need to make the show an entertainment spectacle as well as a football one – and that is its greatest error.
Yes, this was the first episode and like the first week of the new football season it takes a while for things to bed down.
But putting together a football highlights show should, in theory, be pretty easy – put as much football as possible on show and get out of the way.
If you are going to build something around the action then make it insightful, whatever it is: background research, tactical analysis, good quality player or manager interviews etc. Something more than just generic clichés.
Sadly, Channel 5 failed to do this.
The studio audience concept is always a risky one to attempt and this one failed pretty damn well.
If you’re going to have an audience then be prepared to use them and use them well. The best example I’ve seen of this recently was on BT Sport’s Rugby Tonight programme. I haven’t watched it in a while, but last time I saw it they got the audience involved in practical demonstrations, asked them intelligent questions (unsurprisingly getting intelligent answers as a result) and gave them a real purpose for being there. The Football League Tonight audience may as well not have been there how little it was used and how poorly coordinated it was – no microphones available for answering the few generic questions that were posed was a particular highlight.
Bringing in Barnet manager Martin Allen to talk about his team’s first game back in the football league was a good move.
Again, sadly he was rather thrown to the wolves with no preparation time and not having seen the highlights before being asked to commentate on them – poor all around.
You genuinely felt sorry for the guy who was trying his best but just had no support in the studio.
So having talked about the show, what about the football.
Well, the approach to splitting up the highlights from all around the leagues seemed confusing and disjointed at best and downright idiotic at worst.
I’m all for giving bigger exposure to the lower leagues, but again, doing it in a way that seemed to have a little more thought or structure put in to it would go down better – maybe changing the order of the highlights each week would work?
If the show is going to be an hour long, then how about a main game from each division? Five-to-ten minutes of highlights for each of those three games would give plenty of time for the rest of the highlights and other discussions.
There seemed little awareness about another major story which played out in injury time of the Doncaster vs Bury match which saw Jamie Forrester accidentally score for the home side when returning the ball after an injury.
After some form of scuffle the football gods were eased by Bury walking the ball in to the net for the unopposed equaliser.
The incident has been viewed one million times and while that shouldn't be the judge of every news worthy event, it's a pretty good start.
But aside from referencing Forrester's tweet apologising, no further mention was made - no interview with one of the managers or Forrester himself. Nothing.
The final damning and rather bizarre error came with the very last set of highlights.
This included the Birmingham vs Reading game where Reading had a potential equaliser disallowed after a shot hit the crossbar, bounced down and out.
At first (blurry) glance it appeared the ball may have crossed the line, but it was difficult to say.
On returning to the studio the first words we heard were from George Riley saying: “It looked in, that Reading goal.”
Kelly Caites replied: “I’m going to have to see it again.”
Which prompted Riley to add: “We’ll watch it later.”
"NOOOOOOOOOO!" I (and I suspect hundreds of thousands of other fans) screamed.
This is the whole point of a football highlights show. You’re the ones with control of the footage, show it again.
Can you imagine the Match of the Day or Sky Sports crew just passing over a major incident like that?
To be honest, there really is no competition to Sky Sports News’ Goals Express for football league highlights right now.
Channel 5 could learn from that by just sticking to the football.
A football blog dedicated to statistically analysing the Championship
Wednesday, 12 August 2015
Friday, 7 August 2015
Cardiff City season preview 2015-16: A defence of Whittingham and Le Fondre
A messy start
Last season was a bit of a mess for Cardiff.
This time last year the club was still in the midst of the colour change debacle while Ole Gunnar Solskjar was bringing in half of Europe to play.
And there was of course the aftershock of a pretty awful solitary Premier League season.
Using shot statistics to explain Cardiff progress last season is actually reasonably straight forward.
For those not familiar with shot share measures, they are a pretty good indicator of which teams are most likely to be successful over the longer term (ie a full season). While individual games can have significant variations and “luck”, being able to consistently outshoot your opponents is a good predictor for future success.
As an indication of this, in last season’s Championship five of the top six total shot share teams (this includes all shots which are blocked, miss the target, are saved or scored) finished in the top six places.
And using only shots on target (shots which were either saved or scored), all the top six performers in this category finished in the top six of the table.
The league average for both these measurements is 50% - for every one shot you take, your opponent takes one.
OGS’s team started the season with a curious split in shot metrics.
Solskjar had a truly awful overall 39.5% shot share (ie of every 100 shots taken in games played, Cardiff took 39.5, and the opponents took 60.5).
But the shots on target share was a good looking 52.9% (this time, for every 100 shots on target taken in games played, Cardiff took 52.9, but only faced 47.1).
But that difference was not sustainable and it was a falling shots on target share which saw results slide quickly and soon after prompted OGS’ departure just seven games into the season.
Russell Slade eventually took over and with some pretty average football righted the ship, at least taking it to mediocrity with a league average 49.9% shot share during his 37 games in charge. So while it was not pretty, Slade at least got the job done, to a certain degree.
Slade’s tactics got Cardiff taking 12.91 shots per game – a noticeable improvement from OGS’ 10.43 mark but still only more than Wigan, Blackpool, Leeds and Charlton. However he also cut the shots conceded substantially, from 16 under the Norwegian to just 12.97.
That one statistic alone shows how poor Solskjar’s defensive planning was – a competent lower league manager came in and knocked four shots off the total conceded per game.
The shots on target share settled at 48.4% over Slade’s time too – below average but not hideous.
The chart below shows the cumulative total to that point in the season of three key shot metrics - shot share, shots on target share, and PDO. PDO is a strange beast, but can be used as an approximation to natural variance and/or "luck". Sure OGS got killed by a massive PDO slump finishing at game number seven (his last) but this just emphasised the falling other metrics.
So if these numbers stay true to form for the coming term then it looks like another season of mid-table mediocrity for the Bluebirds, unless some special players can drag the team forward.
Pondering Le Fondre
Speaking of which, player management has been questionable in many respects, particularly up front.
Adam Le Fondre was brought in with much fanfare, played out of position, given poor service, substituted, slagged off and then sent on loan to Bolton – where put in the right position he succeeded.
Indeed, in 23 appearances totaling 1,640 mins with Cardiff (an average of 71 mins per appearance) Le Fondre took just 1.6 shots per game – with only 1.2 coming inside the 18 yard box. In contrast, at Bolton in 17 appearances totaling 1,414 mins (average of 83 mins per game) he basically doubled his output to 3.1 shots per game with 2.2 coming from the area.
Perhaps unsurprisingly his non-penalty goals scored went from 0.1/90 at Cardiff to 0.4/90 – on par with Callum Wilson, Troy Deeney and others in the top twenty Championship forwards. So hence, in all their wisdom Cardiff have sent Le Fondre back on loan for the season – this time to Wolves.
Something I missed in my first draft of this post was Le Fondre’s non-shooting contribution. In his time at Cardiff he also contributed 1.3 key passes per 90 – good for fourth best at the club last season.
So even though he was largely played out of position, Le Fondre was still creating chances and generally being a positive influence. Unsurprisingly this number dropped at Bolton when he was the one on the end of the key passes, taking the shots and scoring the goals.
Key players
More encouragingly Slade seems ready to give Joe Mason a decent run in the side. At 24 Mason should now be ready to make his mark and has had a good pre-season.Over the last two seasons in limited minutes split between Cardiff and loan spells at Bolton (again) he’s hovered around 2.2-2.6 shots/90, with around 2/90 from inside the area. He averaged 0.5 NPG/90 in 1,016 minutes at Bolton in 2013/14 and 0.4 NPG/90 in 852 mins with the Trotters last season.
I wonder what a Le Fondre-Mason strike force could do for a well organised Cardiff attack?
In terms of those players who played at least 1,000 league minutes at the club last season, it was Anthony Pilkington who led the way with 2.8 shots/90, although 1.6/90 came from outside the 18 yard box. Kenwynne Jones (2.4/90), Craig Noone (2.2/90), Eoin Doyle (2.1/90) and the aforementioned Le Fondre rounded out the top five.
Let’s talk about Whitts
For some reason Peter Whittingham is one of the most controversial figures at Cardiff City. As far as his attacking, creative play goes I cannot see why.Yes, we’d all love a Yaya Toure in his prime: tackling everything that moves, playing killer throughballs and scoring stunning free kicks. But this is the Championship and those players generally are not here.
But Peter Whittingham is - and we should be thankful for him.
Last season Whittingham led Cardiff in key passes by a country mile – creating opportunities at a rate of 2.2/90 minutes. (Second place went to Noone with 1.6/90. That combined with his shot numbers underlines Noone’s importance to the team.)
As might be expected Whittingham’s key pass rate was an improvement on the previous season in the Premier League (1.8/90).
But so was his tackles per 90 (1.7 vs 1.3).
Indeed of all the defensive metrics available only clearances (1.5 vs 2.3) dropped from the Premier League season, and that is likely due to Cardiff not being hemmed in their own end for the vast majority of play.
Perhaps the other notable statistic is that Whittingham took fewer shots last season (1.2/90) compared to the top division (1.6/90). Was this a trade-off reflecting a different on-pitch role – playing more key passes setting up others rather than taking shots?
Whitts’ key pass rate was also the 19th best in the division – not a bad showing at all especially as Wes Hoolahan (33) and Craig Conway (30) were the only other over 30 years old players to crack that list.
It is hard to explain why Whittingham is such a divisive player in the stands, but the numbers on the pitch tell a very different story.
Here's hoping for a less eventful but more successful season than the last one.
Thursday, 4 June 2015
Bundesliga 2014/15: Klopp's finale and who deserved relegation
I’ve dipped in to the Bundesliga a couple of times this season, mostly, it has to be admitted, to gawp at the goings-on at Dortmund.
But I also spent a bit of time actually watching the Bundesliga too this season and it was just about the only one of the five major European leagues to have any real form of race on the last day of the season.
Indeed, the chaos around the relegation places made for gripping viewing on that last afternoon.
In the end Stuttgart completed their great escape by winning at Paderborn in a result that also relegated the hosts.
Stuttgart actually came from behind to win both their last two games – vs Hamburg and Paderborn.
But did Paderborn and Freiburg deserve to be relegated?
Well, it seems Paderborn at the very least can consider themselves unfortunate and arguably fully undeserving of relegation.
Certainly their overall shot share was a very respectable 0.48 (only ninth worst in the division).
And while their shots on target share throughout the season was less impressive, it only dropped to sixth worst.
However, the kicker is, of course, that Paderborn had the worst PDO in the league.
That mark of 85.43 was a full eight points below their nearest relegation contender (Hannover) and ten less than the next (Hamburg).
I’ve not watch much of Paderborn to suggest any of the reasons for this awful PDO.
According to WhoScored Paderborn did take the third highest percentage of shots from outside the 18 yard box (47%), and the joint fewest (along with five others) inside the six yard box (5%), and were fifth worst at taking shots from central areas (59%).
Combine that with being the equal second worst (with two others) at allowing shots from within the six yard box (8%) and eighth worst at allowing attempts from the centre (62%) and we begin to see some of their problems.
But still, Hamburg were worse in their own six yard box (9%) with Stuttgart not far behind (7%).
Either way you splice it, it seems that to me that Paderborn were at least a little lucky to go down.
A similar, though slightly weaker argument, can also be made for Freiburg who will be plying their trade in Bundesliga 2 next season too.
However, the real beneficiaries from this are Hamburg and (to a lesser extent) Hertha Berlin, who both posted some rather poor shot share numbers.
Indeed were it down to me I might have relegated Hamburg just for their 37% share of shots on target. But that was only “good” enough to earn them a second successive relegation playoff, which they duly won, beating Karlsruhe 3-2 on aggregate.
Further up the table Borussia Monchengladbach certainly rode their luck and the second highest PDO in the league to get in to the Champions League places. With rather average shot share and shots on target share numbers (certainly for a top three team) unless great strides are made with either the playing staff or tactics (or possibly both) it seems unlikely BMG will cause too much trouble in the Champions League next season.
And they could even slip back considerably in the Bundesliga.
But of course the real story of the Bundesliga season was the aforementioned adventures in Dortmund.
It’s quite remarkable that despite owning a PDO score just two points better than poor Paderborn that BVB still managed to finish seventh.
Is that the cost of one departure (Lewandowski) too many?
Perhaps more remarkably, Dortmund continued to improve their shot share and shots on target share numbers throughout the season - moving from 0.645 and 0.583 respectively in week nine to 0.663 and 0.629 by the end. Wow.
But their PDO remained stubbornly sunk well below 90.
If Dortmund had managed to reach a PDO over 90 they surely would have easily finished in the Europa League spots. And somewhere near 100 may have even seen them recovering sufficiently to battle with Leverkusen for fourth.
That would have completed a quite remarkable turnaround from the mid-season horror show that was the Bundesliga table.
But it was not to be and Klopp’s intended fairytale ending is, while not quite a nightmare, certainly a bittersweet one.
So as we can see, from the Bundesliga season, while a shorter schedule has the advantages of generally being less demanding on players, it certainly does not help with the sample size and leaves the possibility for a greater effect on natural football variance to take effect.
But I also spent a bit of time actually watching the Bundesliga too this season and it was just about the only one of the five major European leagues to have any real form of race on the last day of the season.
| Position | Team | Played | Won | Drawn | Lost | Goals For | Goals Against | Goal Difference | Points |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bayern Munich | 34 | 25 | 4 | 5 | 80 | 18 | 62 | 79 |
| 2 | Wolfsburg | 34 | 20 | 9 | 5 | 72 | 38 | 34 | 69 |
| 3 | M'gladbach | 34 | 19 | 9 | 6 | 53 | 26 | 27 | 66 |
| 4 | Leverkusen | 34 | 17 | 10 | 7 | 62 | 37 | 25 | 61 |
| 5 | Augsburg | 34 | 15 | 4 | 15 | 43 | 43 | 0 | 49 |
| 6 | Schalke 04 | 34 | 13 | 9 | 12 | 42 | 40 | 2 | 48 |
| 7 | Dortmund | 34 | 13 | 7 | 14 | 47 | 42 | 5 | 46 |
| 8 | Hoffenheim | 34 | 12 | 8 | 14 | 49 | 55 | -6 | 44 |
| 9 | Ein Frankfurt | 34 | 11 | 10 | 13 | 56 | 62 | -6 | 43 |
| 10 | Werder Bremen | 34 | 11 | 10 | 13 | 50 | 65 | -15 | 43 |
| 11 | Mainz | 34 | 9 | 13 | 12 | 45 | 47 | -2 | 40 |
| 12 | FC Koln | 34 | 9 | 13 | 12 | 34 | 40 | -6 | 40 |
| 13 | Hannover | 34 | 9 | 10 | 15 | 40 | 56 | -16 | 37 |
| 14 | Stuttgart | 34 | 9 | 9 | 16 | 42 | 60 | -18 | 36 |
| 15 | Hertha | 34 | 9 | 8 | 17 | 36 | 52 | -16 | 35 |
| 16 | Hamburg | 34 | 9 | 8 | 17 | 25 | 50 | -25 | 35 |
| 17 | Freiburg | 34 | 7 | 13 | 14 | 36 | 47 | -11 | 34 |
| 18 | Paderborn | 34 | 7 | 10 | 17 | 31 | 65 | -34 | 31 |
Indeed, the chaos around the relegation places made for gripping viewing on that last afternoon.
In the end Stuttgart completed their great escape by winning at Paderborn in a result that also relegated the hosts.
Stuttgart actually came from behind to win both their last two games – vs Hamburg and Paderborn.
But did Paderborn and Freiburg deserve to be relegated?
| Position | Team | Shots for total | Shots against total | Corsi/TSR | shots on target for total | shots on target against total | Shots on target share | Shooting % For | Save % | PDO |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | Augsburg | 458 | 458 | 0.5 | 150 | 170 | 0.469 | 28.67 | 74.71 | 103.38 |
| 1 | Bayern Munich | 583 | 257 | 0.694 | 238 | 95 | 0.715 | 33.61 | 81.05 | 114.66 |
| 7 | Dortmund | 567 | 288 | 0.663 | 190 | 112 | 0.629 | 24.73 | 62.5 | 87.23 |
| 9 | Ein Frankfurt | 426 | 430 | 0.498 | 171 | 195 | 0.467 | 32.75 | 68.21 | 100.96 |
| 12 | FC Koln | 362 | 463 | 0.439 | 126 | 161 | 0.439 | 26.97 | 75.16 | 102.13 |
| 17 | Freiburg | 385 | 515 | 0.428 | 158 | 200 | 0.441 | 22.79 | 76.5 | 99.29 |
| 16 | Hamburg | 364 | 494 | 0.424 | 114 | 189 | 0.376 | 21.92 | 73.55 | 95.47 |
| 13 | Hannover | 384 | 458 | 0.456 | 145 | 161 | 0.474 | 27.6 | 65.21 | 92.81 |
| 15 | Hertha | 297 | 425 | 0.411 | 107 | 156 | 0.407 | 33.62 | 66.67 | 100.29 |
| 8 | Hoffenheim | 501 | 453 | 0.525 | 171 | 157 | 0.521 | 28.65 | 64.96 | 93.61 |
| 4 | Leverkusen | 554 | 299 | 0.65 | 192 | 128 | 0.6 | 32.3 | 71.08 | 103.38 |
| 11 | Mainz | 437 | 482 | 0.475 | 145 | 175 | 0.453 | 31.04 | 73.15 | 104.19 |
| 3 | M'gladbach | 424 | 522 | 0.448 | 174 | 151 | 0.535 | 30.46 | 82.78 | 113.24 |
| 18 | Paderborn | 454 | 492 | 0.48 | 140 | 177 | 0.442 | 22.15 | 63.28 | 85.43 |
| 6 | Schalke 04 | 418 | 537 | 0.438 | 153 | 174 | 0.468 | 27.46 | 77 | 104.47 |
| 14 | Stuttgart | 411 | 472 | 0.466 | 138 | 179 | 0.435 | 30.43 | 66.47 | 96.9 |
| 10 | Werder Bremen | 415 | 499 | 0.454 | 170 | 163 | 0.51 | 29.4 | 60.14 | 89.54 |
| 2 | Wolfsburg | 522 | 418 | 0.555 | 205 | 144 | 0.587 | 35.13 | 73.6 | 108.73 |
Well, it seems Paderborn at the very least can consider themselves unfortunate and arguably fully undeserving of relegation.
Certainly their overall shot share was a very respectable 0.48 (only ninth worst in the division).
And while their shots on target share throughout the season was less impressive, it only dropped to sixth worst.
However, the kicker is, of course, that Paderborn had the worst PDO in the league.
That mark of 85.43 was a full eight points below their nearest relegation contender (Hannover) and ten less than the next (Hamburg).
I’ve not watch much of Paderborn to suggest any of the reasons for this awful PDO.
According to WhoScored Paderborn did take the third highest percentage of shots from outside the 18 yard box (47%), and the joint fewest (along with five others) inside the six yard box (5%), and were fifth worst at taking shots from central areas (59%).
Combine that with being the equal second worst (with two others) at allowing shots from within the six yard box (8%) and eighth worst at allowing attempts from the centre (62%) and we begin to see some of their problems.
But still, Hamburg were worse in their own six yard box (9%) with Stuttgart not far behind (7%).
Either way you splice it, it seems that to me that Paderborn were at least a little lucky to go down.
A similar, though slightly weaker argument, can also be made for Freiburg who will be plying their trade in Bundesliga 2 next season too.
However, the real beneficiaries from this are Hamburg and (to a lesser extent) Hertha Berlin, who both posted some rather poor shot share numbers.
Indeed were it down to me I might have relegated Hamburg just for their 37% share of shots on target. But that was only “good” enough to earn them a second successive relegation playoff, which they duly won, beating Karlsruhe 3-2 on aggregate.
Further up the table Borussia Monchengladbach certainly rode their luck and the second highest PDO in the league to get in to the Champions League places. With rather average shot share and shots on target share numbers (certainly for a top three team) unless great strides are made with either the playing staff or tactics (or possibly both) it seems unlikely BMG will cause too much trouble in the Champions League next season.
And they could even slip back considerably in the Bundesliga.
But of course the real story of the Bundesliga season was the aforementioned adventures in Dortmund.
It’s quite remarkable that despite owning a PDO score just two points better than poor Paderborn that BVB still managed to finish seventh.
Is that the cost of one departure (Lewandowski) too many?
Perhaps more remarkably, Dortmund continued to improve their shot share and shots on target share numbers throughout the season - moving from 0.645 and 0.583 respectively in week nine to 0.663 and 0.629 by the end. Wow.
But their PDO remained stubbornly sunk well below 90.
If Dortmund had managed to reach a PDO over 90 they surely would have easily finished in the Europa League spots. And somewhere near 100 may have even seen them recovering sufficiently to battle with Leverkusen for fourth.
That would have completed a quite remarkable turnaround from the mid-season horror show that was the Bundesliga table.
But it was not to be and Klopp’s intended fairytale ending is, while not quite a nightmare, certainly a bittersweet one.
So as we can see, from the Bundesliga season, while a shorter schedule has the advantages of generally being less demanding on players, it certainly does not help with the sample size and leaves the possibility for a greater effect on natural football variance to take effect.
Sunday, 24 May 2015
League One: 2014/15 the (un)luckiest teams in the Football League
While League Two was reasonably well behaved according to shot metrics, League One, or at least the bottom half, decided to throw most of that out of the window.
If we start at the top, Bristol City locked up the title a good few weeks early but finished the season with an astronomical PDO of almost 120 – the highest in the whole of the football league.
Bristol’s shooting % and save % were both 10 percentage points above average and of course each was the highest mark in the division.
The Robins had enjoyed a high PDO 115 all season but far from regressing over the closing weeks (see County, Derby) they actually increased their PDO – that’s what happens when you stick six past Bradford and eight past Walsall in two of the last four games. But the Robins were only sixth in shot share (Corsi/TSR) and fourth in shots on target share over the season – both around ten percentage points off the top team, MK Dons.
Indeed, while MK Dons are not well liked around the football league for their move away from south west London, it is hard to argue that they do not deserve promotion. Preston and Swindon (in that order) round out the top three in both the shot share categories and so it is gratifying to see that one of them will be promoted via the playoffs.
At the other end things got a bit uglier.
I have genuine sympathy for two of the relegated teams – Yeovil (yes, Yeovil who finished dead last by a country mile) and Leyton Orient.
Both these teams had respectable (in Orient’s case, very respectable) shot share numbers but got burned by PDO and what I can only presume is a series of horrible coinciding results.
I have genuine sympathy for two of the relegated teams – Yeovil (yes, Yeovil who finished dead last by a country mile) and Leyton Orient.
Both these teams had respectable (in Orient’s case, very respectable) shot share numbers but got burned by PDO and what I can only presume is a series of horrible coinciding results.
As PDO giveth in the form of Bristol City, PDO taketh away – in this case Yeovil suffered the worst PDO in the entire football league. (Yes worse even than Blackpool.)
So even some reasonably lower mid-table shot share numbers (Yeovil were almost dead even on shots on target share) could not save them from a horrible ending.
But the real violin lament is saved for the east London side. Orient were ninth best in both overall shot share and shots on target share.
Think about that for a minute… the ninth best team in the division got so badly burned by PDO (a whisker away from having the second worst PDO in League One) that they ended up in the second relegation spot.
The final table lies, and does it to a significant extent.
With those two unfortunate victims of luck, variance and awful coincidence taking the bottom two relegation spots, it meant the likes of Gillingham, Barnsley and (most frustratingly) Crewe all survived. Indeed, if you need another example of how powerful PDO can be, Crawley Town, the worst team in the entire football league, were a last day win away from safety.
And despite Crewe battling Crawley for that title, Notts County just couldn’t wriggle free of the relegation zone themselves and Crewe escaped.
Looking at the wider picture, it is good again to see the division as a whole taking greater effect from shot share and shots on target share than PDO – but that will be of little comfort to a handful of teams at either end of the table whose futures could have been so different.
If we start at the top, Bristol City locked up the title a good few weeks early but finished the season with an astronomical PDO of almost 120 – the highest in the whole of the football league.
Bristol’s shooting % and save % were both 10 percentage points above average and of course each was the highest mark in the division.
| Position | Team | Played | Won | Drawn | Lost | Goals For | Goals Against | Goal Difference | Points |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bristol City | 46 | 29 | 12 | 5 | 96 | 38 | 58 | 99 |
| 2 | Milton Keynes Dons | 46 | 27 | 10 | 9 | 101 | 44 | 57 | 91 |
| 3 | Preston | 46 | 25 | 14 | 7 | 79 | 40 | 39 | 89 |
| 4 | Swindon | 46 | 23 | 10 | 13 | 76 | 57 | 19 | 79 |
| 5 | Sheffield United | 46 | 19 | 14 | 13 | 66 | 53 | 13 | 71 |
| 6 | Chesterfield | 46 | 19 | 12 | 15 | 68 | 55 | 13 | 69 |
| 7 | Bradford | 46 | 17 | 14 | 15 | 55 | 55 | 65 | |
| 8 | Rochdale | 46 | 19 | 6 | 21 | 72 | 66 | 6 | 63 |
| 9 | Peterboro | 46 | 18 | 9 | 19 | 53 | 56 | -3 | 63 |
| 10 | Fleetwood Town | 46 | 17 | 12 | 17 | 49 | 52 | -3 | 63 |
| 11 | Barnsley | 46 | 17 | 11 | 18 | 62 | 61 | 1 | 62 |
| 12 | Gillingham | 46 | 16 | 14 | 16 | 65 | 66 | -1 | 62 |
| 13 | Doncaster | 46 | 16 | 13 | 17 | 58 | 62 | -4 | 61 |
| 14 | Walsall | 46 | 14 | 17 | 15 | 50 | 54 | -4 | 59 |
| 15 | Oldham | 46 | 14 | 15 | 17 | 54 | 67 | -13 | 57 |
| 16 | Scunthorpe | 46 | 14 | 14 | 18 | 62 | 75 | -13 | 56 |
| 17 | Coventry | 46 | 13 | 16 | 17 | 49 | 60 | -11 | 55 |
| 18 | Port Vale | 46 | 15 | 9 | 22 | 55 | 65 | -10 | 54 |
| 19 | Colchester | 46 | 14 | 10 | 22 | 58 | 77 | -19 | 52 |
| 20 | Crewe | 46 | 14 | 10 | 22 | 43 | 75 | -32 | 52 |
| 21 | Notts County | 46 | 12 | 14 | 20 | 45 | 63 | -18 | 50 |
| 22 | Crawley Town | 46 | 13 | 11 | 22 | 53 | 79 | -26 | 50 |
| 23 | Leyton Orient | 46 | 12 | 13 | 21 | 59 | 69 | -10 | 49 |
| 24 | Yeovil | 46 | 10 | 10 | 26 | 36 | 75 | -39 | 40 |
The Robins had enjoyed a high PDO 115 all season but far from regressing over the closing weeks (see County, Derby) they actually increased their PDO – that’s what happens when you stick six past Bradford and eight past Walsall in two of the last four games. But the Robins were only sixth in shot share (Corsi/TSR) and fourth in shots on target share over the season – both around ten percentage points off the top team, MK Dons.
Indeed, while MK Dons are not well liked around the football league for their move away from south west London, it is hard to argue that they do not deserve promotion. Preston and Swindon (in that order) round out the top three in both the shot share categories and so it is gratifying to see that one of them will be promoted via the playoffs.
| Position | Team | Shots for total | Shots against total | Corsi/TSR | shots on target for total | shots on target against total | Shots on target share | Shooting % For | Save % | PDO |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11 | Barnsley | 437 | 506 | 0.463 | 177 | 222 | 0.444 | 35.03 | 72.52 | 107.55 |
| 7 | Bradford | 469 | 446 | 0.513 | 205 | 169 | 0.548 | 26.82 | 67.47 | 94.29 |
| 1 | Bristol City | 573 | 479 | 0.545 | 240 | 185 | 0.565 | 39.99 | 79.45 | 119.45 |
| 6 | Chesterfield | 551 | 419 | 0.568 | 225 | 192 | 0.54 | 30.22 | 71.36 | 101.58 |
| 19 | Colchester | 499 | 545 | 0.478 | 216 | 237 | 0.477 | 26.84 | 67.52 | 94.36 |
| 17 | Coventry | 484 | 439 | 0.524 | 180 | 169 | 0.516 | 27.23 | 64.49 | 91.71 |
| 22 | Crawley Town | 369 | 660 | 0.359 | 134 | 285 | 0.32 | 39.57 | 72.28 | 111.85 |
| 20 | Crewe | 356 | 660 | 0.35 | 171 | 269 | 0.389 | 25.15 | 72.12 | 97.27 |
| 13 | Doncaster | 537 | 446 | 0.546 | 225 | 177 | 0.559 | 25.79 | 64.99 | 90.78 |
| 10 | Fleetwood Town | 464 | 603 | 0.435 | 193 | 213 | 0.475 | 25.38 | 75.59 | 100.97 |
| 12 | Gillingham | 438 | 583 | 0.429 | 180 | 233 | 0.436 | 36.11 | 71.67 | 107.78 |
| 23 | Leyton Orient | 514 | 466 | 0.524 | 234 | 201 | 0.538 | 25.22 | 65.67 | 90.89 |
| 2 | Milton Keynes Dons | 673 | 366 | 0.648 | 288 | 151 | 0.656 | 35.07 | 70.88 | 105.95 |
| 21 | Notts County | 477 | 642 | 0.426 | 203 | 260 | 0.438 | 22.17 | 75.78 | 97.94 |
| 15 | Oldham | 459 | 451 | 0.505 | 182 | 188 | 0.492 | 29.67 | 64.35 | 94.02 |
| 9 | Peterboro | 503 | 509 | 0.497 | 206 | 203 | 0.503 | 25.74 | 72.42 | 98.17 |
| 18 | Port Vale | 476 | 542 | 0.468 | 193 | 234 | 0.452 | 28.49 | 72.21 | 100.7 |
| 3 | Preston | 631 | 404 | 0.61 | 254 | 150 | 0.629 | 31.1 | 73.33 | 104.43 |
| 8 | Rochdale | 483 | 469 | 0.507 | 202 | 201 | 0.501 | 35.65 | 67.18 | 102.83 |
| 16 | Scunthorpe | 476 | 543 | 0.467 | 204 | 235 | 0.465 | 30.38 | 68.07 | 98.46 |
| 5 | Sheffield United | 508 | 432 | 0.54 | 203 | 167 | 0.549 | 32.52 | 68.26 | 100.78 |
| 4 | Swindon | 590 | 422 | 0.583 | 255 | 180 | 0.586 | 29.8 | 68.32 | 98.11 |
| 14 | Walsall | 523 | 445 | 0.54 | 181 | 198 | 0.478 | 27.62 | 72.71 | 100.34 |
| 24 | Yeovil | 455 | 468 | 0.493 | 160 | 192 | 0.455 | 22.51 | 60.93 | 83.43 |
At the other end things got a bit uglier.
I have genuine sympathy for two of the relegated teams – Yeovil (yes, Yeovil who finished dead last by a country mile) and Leyton Orient.
Both these teams had respectable (in Orient’s case, very respectable) shot share numbers but got burned by PDO and what I can only presume is a series of horrible coinciding results.
I have genuine sympathy for two of the relegated teams – Yeovil (yes, Yeovil who finished dead last by a country mile) and Leyton Orient.
Both these teams had respectable (in Orient’s case, very respectable) shot share numbers but got burned by PDO and what I can only presume is a series of horrible coinciding results.
As PDO giveth in the form of Bristol City, PDO taketh away – in this case Yeovil suffered the worst PDO in the entire football league. (Yes worse even than Blackpool.)
So even some reasonably lower mid-table shot share numbers (Yeovil were almost dead even on shots on target share) could not save them from a horrible ending.
But the real violin lament is saved for the east London side. Orient were ninth best in both overall shot share and shots on target share.
Think about that for a minute… the ninth best team in the division got so badly burned by PDO (a whisker away from having the second worst PDO in League One) that they ended up in the second relegation spot.
The final table lies, and does it to a significant extent.
With those two unfortunate victims of luck, variance and awful coincidence taking the bottom two relegation spots, it meant the likes of Gillingham, Barnsley and (most frustratingly) Crewe all survived. Indeed, if you need another example of how powerful PDO can be, Crawley Town, the worst team in the entire football league, were a last day win away from safety.
And despite Crewe battling Crawley for that title, Notts County just couldn’t wriggle free of the relegation zone themselves and Crewe escaped.
Looking at the wider picture, it is good again to see the division as a whole taking greater effect from shot share and shots on target share than PDO – but that will be of little comfort to a handful of teams at either end of the table whose futures could have been so different.
Saturday, 23 May 2015
League Two: 2014/15 analytics round-up
Statistically speaking, League Two is one of the easiest divisions to look at this year.
The top five teams in terms of overall shot share (Corsi/TSR) and shots on target share filled the top five end of season league positions.
The only teams that can really consider themselves unlucky in the division are Northampton and Oxford – both of whom had very good shot metrics but were bitten by a combination of their own below average PDO and slightly above average PDO for their competitors.
If both these clubs can stay the course with their current squads, managers and plans then they should have a very good chance of promotion next season.
Earlier in the season Newport and Luton flirted with promotion and the playoffs, but their high PDO scores proved to be unmaintainable and they both slipped outside the top seven.
I discussed the arrival of Terry Butcher at Newport in an earlier post, but the Exiles have since discarded all except eight of their squad, so knowing what to expect at Rodney Parade next season is pretty tough.
At the other end of the table Hartlepool’s escape from the clutches of relegation was a well-publicised one, especially given they were one of the worst teams in the league.
But even more remarkable (and less publicised) was Dagenham and Redbridge’s route to mid-table.
Put bluntly, whatever the Daggers’ forwards and goalkeeper were on this season, I want some of it.
The Daggers were even worse (just) than Hartlepool and did flirt with a relegation fight, but ended the season with a mammoth PDO of 115 which saw them comfortably mid-table.
They had the top shooting % in the whole division (four percentage points above the next best – Champions Burton) which was ten points above average and also the fifth highest save %. Can an ageing Jamie Cureton repeat this next year?
I suspect if things don’t change at Dagenham over the summer then the results next year could well be a lot uglier.
Positive PDO has a habit of hiding the faults and flaws of a team.
So with Wycombe and Southend battling for the final promotion spot, statistically speaking at least, I’m quite happy with having four of the top five shots teams going up.
And all of this is nicely rounded-up by the comparing the points teams gained with their shot share, shots on target share and PDO scores over the season.
Compared to the Championship some of the correlations are not quite so strong, but it is heartening to see that shot dominance in both its forms was more strongly rewarded than luck and variance.
The top five teams in terms of overall shot share (Corsi/TSR) and shots on target share filled the top five end of season league positions.
The only teams that can really consider themselves unlucky in the division are Northampton and Oxford – both of whom had very good shot metrics but were bitten by a combination of their own below average PDO and slightly above average PDO for their competitors.
| Position | Team | Played | Won | Drawn | Lost | Goals For | Goals Against | Goal Difference | Points |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Burton | 46 | 28 | 10 | 8 | 69 | 39 | 30 | 94 |
| 2 | Shrewsbury | 46 | 27 | 8 | 11 | 67 | 31 | 36 | 89 |
| 3 | Bury | 46 | 26 | 7 | 13 | 60 | 40 | 20 | 85 |
| 4 | Wycombe | 46 | 23 | 15 | 8 | 67 | 45 | 22 | 84 |
| 5 | Southend | 46 | 24 | 12 | 10 | 54 | 38 | 16 | 84 |
| 6 | Stevenage | 46 | 20 | 12 | 14 | 62 | 54 | 8 | 72 |
| 7 | Plymouth | 46 | 20 | 11 | 15 | 55 | 37 | 18 | 71 |
| 8 | Luton | 46 | 19 | 11 | 16 | 54 | 44 | 10 | 68 |
| 9 | Newport County | 46 | 18 | 11 | 17 | 51 | 54 | -3 | 65 |
| 10 | Exeter | 46 | 17 | 13 | 16 | 61 | 65 | -4 | 64 |
| 11 | Morecambe | 46 | 17 | 12 | 17 | 53 | 52 | 1 | 63 |
| 12 | Northampton | 46 | 18 | 7 | 21 | 67 | 62 | 5 | 61 |
| 13 | Oxford | 46 | 15 | 16 | 15 | 50 | 49 | 1 | 61 |
| 14 | Dag and Red | 46 | 17 | 8 | 21 | 58 | 59 | -1 | 59 |
| 15 | AFC Wimbledon | 46 | 14 | 16 | 16 | 54 | 60 | -6 | 58 |
| 16 | Portsmouth | 46 | 14 | 15 | 17 | 52 | 54 | -2 | 57 |
| 17 | Accrington | 46 | 15 | 11 | 20 | 58 | 77 | -19 | 56 |
| 18 | York | 46 | 11 | 19 | 16 | 46 | 51 | -5 | 52 |
| 19 | Cambridge | 46 | 13 | 12 | 21 | 61 | 66 | -5 | 51 |
| 20 | Carlisle | 46 | 14 | 8 | 24 | 56 | 74 | -18 | 50 |
| 21 | Mansfield | 46 | 13 | 9 | 24 | 38 | 62 | -24 | 48 |
| 22 | Hartlepool | 46 | 12 | 9 | 25 | 39 | 70 | -31 | 45 |
| 23 | Cheltenham | 46 | 9 | 14 | 23 | 40 | 67 | -27 | 41 |
| 24 | Tranmere | 46 | 9 | 12 | 25 | 45 | 67 | -22 | 39 |
If both these clubs can stay the course with their current squads, managers and plans then they should have a very good chance of promotion next season.
Earlier in the season Newport and Luton flirted with promotion and the playoffs, but their high PDO scores proved to be unmaintainable and they both slipped outside the top seven.
I discussed the arrival of Terry Butcher at Newport in an earlier post, but the Exiles have since discarded all except eight of their squad, so knowing what to expect at Rodney Parade next season is pretty tough.
| Position | Team | Shots for total | Shots against total | Corsi/TSR | shots on target for total | shots on target against total | Shots on target share | Shooting % For | Save % | PDO |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 | Accrington | 472 | 518 | 0.477 | 178 | 208 | 0.461 | 32.59 | 62.97 | 95.56 |
| 15 | AFC Wimbledon | 466 | 489 | 0.488 | 187 | 201 | 0.482 | 28.88 | 70.14 | 99.02 |
| 1 | Burton | 503 | 385 | 0.566 | 196 | 138 | 0.587 | 35.22 | 71.74 | 106.95 |
| 3 | Bury | 474 | 385 | 0.552 | 189 | 141 | 0.573 | 31.76 | 71.63 | 103.39 |
| 19 | Cambridge | 468 | 527 | 0.47 | 185 | 195 | 0.487 | 32.99 | 66.16 | 99.15 |
| 20 | Carlisle | 431 | 576 | 0.428 | 159 | 210 | 0.431 | 35.22 | 64.76 | 99.98 |
| 23 | Cheltenham | 373 | 487 | 0.434 | 147 | 214 | 0.407 | 27.21 | 68.7 | 95.91 |
| 14 | Dag and Red | 419 | 581 | 0.419 | 147 | 242 | 0.378 | 39.45 | 75.62 | 115.07 |
| 10 | Exeter | 476 | 525 | 0.476 | 193 | 184 | 0.512 | 31.6 | 64.67 | 96.26 |
| 22 | Hartlepool | 394 | 505 | 0.438 | 137 | 223 | 0.381 | 28.45 | 68.62 | 97.07 |
| 8 | Luton | 457 | 516 | 0.47 | 173 | 204 | 0.459 | 31.23 | 78.43 | 109.66 |
| 21 | Mansfield | 464 | 491 | 0.486 | 174 | 192 | 0.476 | 21.83 | 67.69 | 89.53 |
| 11 | Morecambe | 452 | 572 | 0.442 | 196 | 206 | 0.488 | 27.03 | 74.74 | 101.78 |
| 9 | Newport County | 462 | 409 | 0.53 | 176 | 188 | 0.483 | 28.98 | 71.28 | 100.26 |
| 12 | Northampton | 503 | 436 | 0.536 | 207 | 174 | 0.543 | 32.38 | 64.38 | 96.76 |
| 13 | Oxford | 461 | 395 | 0.538 | 181 | 145 | 0.555 | 27.63 | 66.22 | 93.85 |
| 7 | Plymouth | 502 | 454 | 0.525 | 188 | 166 | 0.531 | 29.26 | 77.71 | 106.97 |
| 16 | Portsmouth | 445 | 440 | 0.503 | 188 | 184 | 0.505 | 27.67 | 70.67 | 98.34 |
| 2 | Shrewsbury | 563 | 335 | 0.627 | 242 | 138 | 0.637 | 27.69 | 77.53 | 105.21 |
| 5 | Southend | 541 | 421 | 0.562 | 230 | 156 | 0.596 | 23.48 | 75.63 | 99.11 |
| 6 | Stevenage | 418 | 410 | 0.505 | 182 | 162 | 0.529 | 34.06 | 66.65 | 100.71 |
| 24 | Tranmere | 432 | 444 | 0.493 | 167 | 207 | 0.447 | 26.95 | 67.62 | 94.57 |
| 4 | Wycombe | 475 | 382 | 0.554 | 195 | 147 | 0.57 | 34.35 | 69.37 | 103.72 |
| 18 | York | 547 | 515 | 0.515 | 222 | 214 | 0.509 | 20.72 | 76.18 | 96.9 |
At the other end of the table Hartlepool’s escape from the clutches of relegation was a well-publicised one, especially given they were one of the worst teams in the league.
But even more remarkable (and less publicised) was Dagenham and Redbridge’s route to mid-table.
Put bluntly, whatever the Daggers’ forwards and goalkeeper were on this season, I want some of it.
The Daggers were even worse (just) than Hartlepool and did flirt with a relegation fight, but ended the season with a mammoth PDO of 115 which saw them comfortably mid-table.
They had the top shooting % in the whole division (four percentage points above the next best – Champions Burton) which was ten points above average and also the fifth highest save %. Can an ageing Jamie Cureton repeat this next year?
I suspect if things don’t change at Dagenham over the summer then the results next year could well be a lot uglier.
Positive PDO has a habit of hiding the faults and flaws of a team.
So with Wycombe and Southend battling for the final promotion spot, statistically speaking at least, I’m quite happy with having four of the top five shots teams going up.
And all of this is nicely rounded-up by the comparing the points teams gained with their shot share, shots on target share and PDO scores over the season.
Compared to the Championship some of the correlations are not quite so strong, but it is heartening to see that shot dominance in both its forms was more strongly rewarded than luck and variance.
Sunday, 10 May 2015
Terry Butcher did a good job at Hibernian... and should improve Newport County
Terry Butcher was appointed manager of Newport County before the last game of the season and arrived in south Wales with much fanfare.
But why?
Butcher left his previous club (Hibernian) under a fairly substantial cloud and with a much diminished reputation having been at the helm for the majority of the 2013/14 season as Hibs finished second bottom in the then Scottish Premier League.
Hibs relegation was confirmed after the team blew a 3-0 lead from the first leg of the relegation playoff against Hamilton Academicals.
Worse for the Butcher, the Hibees actually owned the worst record in the SPL that season and it was only Hearts’ 15 point deduction for going in to administration that kept them off the bottom of the table.
So what did Newport’s board see in Butcher that makes them think the Exiles are a good place for him to resurrect his managerial career?
Well, as Seth Dobson points out Butcher did a pretty decent job at his previous club (Inverness Caledonian Thistle).
He improved the shots on target share consistently and obtained a better shot share than his first year in charge in each of the following three.
(These figures are for games not involving the Old Firm of Celtic and Rangers who tend to skew the league given their sheer financial dominance.)
But that all came crashing down at Easter Road, right?
Actually, no. Terry Butcher did a pretty good job at Hibs and certainly improved the team’s performances compared to his predecessor Pat Fenlon – although that is not immediately apparent.
Looking at the simple league record it’s a pretty poor show.
Fenlon was ticking over at 1.15 points per games after 13 matches with the team in seventh place.
Butcher’s team went just 0.8 points per game over the remaining 25 games and ended the season in 11th.
But when we look at the shot metrics it was a very different tale.
Fenlon’s team had an overall shot share score (otherwise known as Corsi or Total Shots Ratio) of just 0.451 – meaning out of every 10 shots in a match, Fenlon’s Hibs took just 4.5 of them and conceded 5.5.
And the shots on target share was a paltry 0.437 – again meaning out of every 10 shots on target Fenlon’s team took just 4.37 of them.
What was keeping Fenlon’s team from being dragged into a relegation fight even then was a just below average PDO score of 95.11.
As the next two charts show, at the point of his departure Fenlon's team was almost as bad as Ross County, Hearts and St Mirren.
But PDO is a highly volatile (uncontrollable) statistic which combines goal scoring percentage with save percentage.
A significant element of its variation (around 60%) is based on luck – the “goal off a beachball” factor.
Although it is hard to pinpoint, there does appear to be some influence of managerial tactics and player skill involved in PDO – keep allowing opposing strikers through one-on-one with your goalkeeper and it’s probably not going to end well.
So, the Hibees’ PDO of 95.11 under Fenlon was already below average and would be expected to regress upward slightly to around the 100 point league average over the course of the season.
In other words Hibs (and Terry Butcher when he arrived) were due a little bit of luck.
Instead what they got was an absolute cratering of PDO.
This was despite improved play that saw Butcher reverse Fenlon’s shot share (taking 5.58 shots of every 10) and also make a significant improvement in shots on target share to bring Hibs up to basically league average (taking almost 5 of every ten shots on target).
Butcher improved Hibs' overall shot performance by four shots per game – getting the team to take 2.69 shots per game more and restricting the opposition to 1.32 fewer shots per game.
There was also an improvement in the shots on target total (although not so significantly) with Hibs taking an extra three shots on target every four games.
Unfortunately, Butcher inherited a league average save percentage (around 70%) and saw that drop by 10 percentage points - meaning the team was shipping an inordinate amount of goals.
Meanwhile, the below average scoring percentage stayed right where it was.
Whether this horrible save rate was down to Butcher’s tactical decisions or just dumb luck is hard to say (I didn’t see enough of Hibs games to look at that). But I would usually lean more towards the latter – especially where we have seen both extremes in Butcher’s history at ICT.
At the end of the season that left Hibs looking like this compared to the rest of the league...
.... performances which should have had then in the top eight, and potentially the top six. Instead they finished bottom but one.
So to sum up – Hibs probably sacked Butcher far too readily (although given the relegation it is not surprising) and Newport potentially have a very good manager who should improve the team over the next few years.
Incidentally, Newport ended this League Two season with a very nice 0.53 overall shot share, a not quite so nice 0.483 shots on target share and a pretty much league average PDO of 100.26.
Enjoy the summer Exiles fans.
Labels:
Corsi,
Hibernian,
League Two,
Newport County,
PDO,
Shots on target,
SPL,
Terry Butcher,
TSR
Friday, 8 May 2015
Championship Week 46: The beginning of the end
Well that was quite an end to the Championship season to say the least.
It seems all the excitement that left the title and relegation races in the final few weeks fell in to the playoff race on the final day of the season.
That was quite some experience watching those four games go down to the last goal to decide the final two playoff places.
Of course the headline from most of the media was what a complete collapse to Derby’s season – but of those four teams it should really be focused on Ipswich (and to a lesser extent Brentford) who consistently improved as the season went on.
I pointed out throughout the season that Derby’s lofty perch was acquired by a probably unsustainable PDO and thus it proved – even if it did take a little while to come back down to almost earth.
Indeed, one wonders how Derby’s season would have progressed had the Rams only enjoyed league average (100) PDO all season long.
Yes, there may be some talent effects in PDO, but considering that a 100 PDO would probably have seen Derby hovering somewhere between 13th (their overall shot share) and where they actually finished in 8th, which also matched their shots on target ranking.
In fact Ipswich, with a give-or-take league average only finished sixth despite having the sixth highest overall shot share and fourth highest shots on target share.
Mick McCarthy should be pleased with the way he brought his team together.
From a decidedly slow start the team consistently improved its shots and shots on target share to finish the season well above 50% and 55% respectively.
Brentford too had a slow start but again slowly and steadily improved throughout the season.
Yes their shot stats are boosted somewhat by the massacre of Blackpool, but Mark Warburton and the players should be congratulated for not getting distracted by the announcement over the manager’s future near the end of the season.
Yes, it is more than likely the right decision and you would expect the manager and players to maintain a professional approach, but these sorts of changes can have an impact in unexpected ways.
In this case, it seems to have motivated Warburton and the squad as since then they have continued to improve in the shot metrics.
My biggest concern for the playoffs is Middlesbrough.
I was a big fan of Middlesbrough and their excellent shot metrics early in the season, but it is impossible not to notice their deteriorating metrics since that great start.
They still have very good numbers but the slide is undeniable and not a good trend to be owning. I wouldn’t expect them to maintain the early season score at up around 65%+, but you would expect it to flatten out somewhere – continuing its descent is worrying.
So that leaves Norwich as the only remaining playoff team to look at. And the Canaries have been exemplary all season.
Top in shot share and second in shots on target share, the only thing to scupper Norwich’s season was some awful PDO in the first half of the season.
Local derbies are horrible to predict, so I’m not going to.
But on the balance of the season Norwich are the team which deserve to win the playoffs and return immediately to the Premier League.
Looking at the season as a whole, it is noticeable how quickly the top eight broke clear from the rest of the league and how at the midway stage the bottom three teams were also decided.
Considering the shot metrics it is remarkable how quickly these settled down in to pretty consistent measures that by-and-large lasted the length of the season: Norwich, Bournemouth and Middlesbrough at the top; Blackpool, Leeds and Charlton at the bottom.
By contrast PDO remained more volatile throughout the season with a few teams witnessing remarkable fluxes all the way through – Charlton and Derby to name just two.
Let’s see which of these factors had a stronger impact on the final league table.
This season has appeared something of a volatile one, particularly for the lower 16 teams, as it were.
Indeed, the overall shot share produces a rather relationship (if reasonably weak) to points gained by teams – an r2 value of 0.322.
When we then look at shots on target share we get a much greater link – here we see an r2 value of 0.6848.
But the strongest relationship involves PDO – a mighty r2 score of 0.7555.
The powerful hold that PDO had this season was reflected in some of those teams with poor shot numbers finishing much higher up in the final table and the reverse – good shots teams near the bottom of the table.
It sure was a fun season and I’m looking forward to the playoffs now.
It seems all the excitement that left the title and relegation races in the final few weeks fell in to the playoff race on the final day of the season.
That was quite some experience watching those four games go down to the last goal to decide the final two playoff places.
| Position | Team | Played | Won | Drawn | Lost | Goals For | Goals Against | Goal Difference | Points |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bournemouth | 46 | 26 | 12 | 8 | 98 | 45 | 53 | 90 |
| 2 | Watford | 46 | 27 | 8 | 11 | 91 | 50 | 41 | 89 |
| 3 | Norwich | 46 | 25 | 11 | 10 | 88 | 48 | 40 | 86 |
| 4 | Middlesbrough | 46 | 25 | 10 | 11 | 68 | 37 | 31 | 85 |
| 5 | Brentford | 46 | 23 | 9 | 14 | 78 | 59 | 19 | 78 |
| 6 | Ipswich | 46 | 22 | 12 | 12 | 72 | 54 | 18 | 78 |
| 7 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | 46 | 22 | 12 | 12 | 70 | 56 | 14 | 78 |
| 8 | Derby | 46 | 21 | 14 | 11 | 85 | 56 | 29 | 77 |
| 9 | Blackburn | 46 | 17 | 16 | 13 | 66 | 59 | 7 | 67 |
| 10 | Birmingham | 46 | 16 | 15 | 15 | 54 | 64 | -10 | 63 |
| 11 | Cardiff | 46 | 16 | 14 | 16 | 57 | 61 | -4 | 62 |
| 12 | Charlton | 46 | 14 | 18 | 14 | 54 | 60 | -6 | 60 |
| 13 | Sheffield Wednesday | 46 | 14 | 18 | 14 | 43 | 49 | -6 | 60 |
| 14 | Nottingham Forest | 46 | 15 | 14 | 17 | 71 | 69 | 2 | 59 |
| 15 | Leeds | 46 | 15 | 11 | 20 | 50 | 61 | -11 | 56 |
| 16 | Huddersfield | 46* | 13 | 15 | 17 | 58 | 75 | -17 | 54 |
| 17 | Fulham | 46 | 14 | 10 | 22 | 62 | 83 | -21 | 52 |
| 18 | Bolton | 46 | 13 | 12 | 21 | 54 | 67 | -13 | 51 |
| 19 | Reading | 46 | 13 | 11 | 22 | 48 | 69 | -21 | 50 |
| 20 | Brighton | 46 | 10 | 17 | 19 | 44 | 54 | -10 | 47 |
| 21 | Rotherham | 46 | 11 | 16 | 19 | 46 | 67 | -21 | 46 |
| 22 | Millwall | 46 | 9 | 14 | 23 | 42 | 76 | -34 | 41 |
| 23 | Wigan | 46 | 9 | 12 | 25 | 39 | 64 | -25 | 39 |
| 24 | Blackpool | 46* | 4 | 13 | 28 | 36 | 91 | -55 | 25 |
Of course the headline from most of the media was what a complete collapse to Derby’s season – but of those four teams it should really be focused on Ipswich (and to a lesser extent Brentford) who consistently improved as the season went on.
I pointed out throughout the season that Derby’s lofty perch was acquired by a probably unsustainable PDO and thus it proved – even if it did take a little while to come back down to almost earth.
| Position | Team | Played | Shots for total | Shots against total | Corsi/TSR | shots on target for total | shots on target against total | Shots on target share | Shooting % For | Save % | PDO |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | Birmingham | 46 | 614 | 724 | 0.459 | 204 | 235 | 0.465 | 26.47 | 72.77 | 99.24 |
| 9 | Blackburn | 46 | 694 | 650 | 0.516 | 217 | 219 | 0.498 | 30.41 | 73.06 | 103.47 |
| 24 | Blackpool | 46* | 528 | 746 | 0.414 | 154 | 245 | 0.386 | 23.38 | 62.86 | 86.23 |
| 18 | Bolton | 46 | 584 | 728 | 0.445 | 194 | 243 | 0.444 | 27.84 | 72.43 | 100.26 |
| 1 | Bournemouth | 46 | 767 | 528 | 0.592 | 270 | 154 | 0.637 | 36.3 | 70.78 | 107.08 |
| 5 | Brentford | 46 | 710 | 632 | 0.529 | 266 | 215 | 0.553 | 29.32 | 72.56 | 101.88 |
| 20 | Brighton | 46 | 663 | 579 | 0.534 | 185 | 179 | 0.508 | 23.78 | 69.83 | 93.62 |
| 11 | Cardiff | 46 | 577 | 632 | 0.477 | 173 | 183 | 0.486 | 32.95 | 66.67 | 99.61 |
| 12 | Charlton | 46 | 475 | 751 | 0.387 | 168 | 220 | 0.433 | 32.14 | 72.73 | 104.87 |
| 8 | Derby | 46 | 602 | 584 | 0.508 | 215 | 196 | 0.523 | 39.53 | 71.43 | 110.96 |
| 17 | Fulham | 46 | 601 | 712 | 0.458 | 193 | 246 | 0.44 | 32.12 | 66.26 | 98.38 |
| 16 | Huddersfield | 46* | 662 | 637 | 0.51 | 237 | 212 | 0.528 | 24.47 | 64.62 | 89.1 |
| 6 | Ipswich | 46 | 675 | 605 | 0.527 | 228 | 174 | 0.567 | 31.58 | 68.97 | 100.54 |
| 15 | Leeds | 46 | 529 | 706 | 0.428 | 158 | 218 | 0.42 | 31.65 | 72.02 | 103.66 |
| 4 | Middlesbrough | 46 | 663 | 532 | 0.555 | 214 | 150 | 0.588 | 31.78 | 75.33 | 107.11 |
| 22 | Millwall | 46 | 610 | 601 | 0.504 | 171 | 217 | 0.441 | 24.56 | 64.98 | 89.54 |
| 3 | Norwich | 46 | 740 | 431 | 0.632 | 243 | 154 | 0.612 | 36.21 | 68.83 | 105.05 |
| 14 | Nottingham Forest | 46 | 673 | 649 | 0.509 | 213 | 205 | 0.51 | 33.33 | 66.34 | 99.67 |
| 19 | Reading | 46 | 599 | 574 | 0.511 | 185 | 204 | 0.476 | 25.95 | 66.18 | 92.12 |
| 21 | Rotherham | 46 | 618 | 618 | 0.5 | 189 | 203 | 0.482 | 24.34 | 67 | 91.33 |
| 13 | Sheffield Wednesday | 46 | 600 | 568 | 0.514 | 166 | 181 | 0.478 | 25.9 | 72.93 | 98.83 |
| 2 | Watford | 46 | 668 | 632 | 0.514 | 252 | 206 | 0.55 | 36.11 | 75.73 | 111.84 |
| 23 | Wigan | 46 | 547 | 539 | 0.504 | 155 | 186 | 0.455 | 25.16 | 65.59 | 90.75 |
| 7 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | 46 | 598 | 641 | 0.483 | 198 | 203 | 0.494 | 35.35 | 72.41 | 107.77 |
Indeed, one wonders how Derby’s season would have progressed had the Rams only enjoyed league average (100) PDO all season long.
Yes, there may be some talent effects in PDO, but considering that a 100 PDO would probably have seen Derby hovering somewhere between 13th (their overall shot share) and where they actually finished in 8th, which also matched their shots on target ranking.
In fact Ipswich, with a give-or-take league average only finished sixth despite having the sixth highest overall shot share and fourth highest shots on target share.
Mick McCarthy should be pleased with the way he brought his team together.
From a decidedly slow start the team consistently improved its shots and shots on target share to finish the season well above 50% and 55% respectively.
Brentford too had a slow start but again slowly and steadily improved throughout the season.
Yes their shot stats are boosted somewhat by the massacre of Blackpool, but Mark Warburton and the players should be congratulated for not getting distracted by the announcement over the manager’s future near the end of the season.
Yes, it is more than likely the right decision and you would expect the manager and players to maintain a professional approach, but these sorts of changes can have an impact in unexpected ways.
In this case, it seems to have motivated Warburton and the squad as since then they have continued to improve in the shot metrics.
My biggest concern for the playoffs is Middlesbrough.
I was a big fan of Middlesbrough and their excellent shot metrics early in the season, but it is impossible not to notice their deteriorating metrics since that great start.
They still have very good numbers but the slide is undeniable and not a good trend to be owning. I wouldn’t expect them to maintain the early season score at up around 65%+, but you would expect it to flatten out somewhere – continuing its descent is worrying.
So that leaves Norwich as the only remaining playoff team to look at. And the Canaries have been exemplary all season.
Top in shot share and second in shots on target share, the only thing to scupper Norwich’s season was some awful PDO in the first half of the season.
Local derbies are horrible to predict, so I’m not going to.
But on the balance of the season Norwich are the team which deserve to win the playoffs and return immediately to the Premier League.
Looking at the season as a whole, it is noticeable how quickly the top eight broke clear from the rest of the league and how at the midway stage the bottom three teams were also decided.
Considering the shot metrics it is remarkable how quickly these settled down in to pretty consistent measures that by-and-large lasted the length of the season: Norwich, Bournemouth and Middlesbrough at the top; Blackpool, Leeds and Charlton at the bottom.
By contrast PDO remained more volatile throughout the season with a few teams witnessing remarkable fluxes all the way through – Charlton and Derby to name just two.
Let’s see which of these factors had a stronger impact on the final league table.
This season has appeared something of a volatile one, particularly for the lower 16 teams, as it were.
Indeed, the overall shot share produces a rather relationship (if reasonably weak) to points gained by teams – an r2 value of 0.322.
When we then look at shots on target share we get a much greater link – here we see an r2 value of 0.6848.
But the strongest relationship involves PDO – a mighty r2 score of 0.7555.
The powerful hold that PDO had this season was reflected in some of those teams with poor shot numbers finishing much higher up in the final table and the reverse – good shots teams near the bottom of the table.
It sure was a fun season and I’m looking forward to the playoffs now.
Labels:
Brentford,
Championship,
Corsi,
Derby,
Ipswich,
Middlesbrough,
Norwich City,
PDO,
Shots on target,
TSR
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

































